YouTube welcomes back permabanned creators for a “second chance” but there’s a catch

https://www.dexerto.com/youtube/youtube-welcomes-back-permabanned-creators-for-a-second-chance-but-theres-a-catch-3264988/

Michael Gwilliam Oct 09, 2025 · 2 mins read
YouTube welcomes back permabanned creators for a “second chance” but there’s a catch
Share this

YouTube is offering some permanently banned creators a shot at redemption, but getting back on the platform comes with a major catch.

On October 9, 2025, the company announced a new pilot program that will let creators with previously terminated channels request to return to the site. Those accepted will be allowed to create a brand-new YouTube channel and even re-upload old content, but they’ll be starting from zero.

“There are many creators with terminated channels who deserve a second chance, especially as YouTube has evolved and changed over the past 20 years,” the platform said in a blog post. “We’ve heard loud and clear from creators that they want more options to return to YouTube.”

YouTube gives banned creators a “second chance”

Only creators who’ve been banned for over a year will be eligible to apply. YouTube is rolling out the program slowly and will review applications individually based on factors like the severity and persistence of past violations.

Not every ban qualifies. Creators who were removed for copyright infringement or violating the Creator Responsibility policy won’t be eligible.

If accepted, creators will launch new channels with no subscribers, no monetization, and no safety net. They’ll have to rebuild their communities from scratch.

“A new channel means a fresh start — creators can build back their community, upload old content (that follows our Community Guidelines), and apply for YPP once their new channel is eligible,” YouTube explained.

The platform also made clear that if someone gets banned again, there won’t be another chance.

YouTube’s decision comes amid growing creator criticism over permanent bans with no path to redemption. This new program signals a shift toward offering controlled second chances, but on the company’s terms, similar to how Twitch began bringing back streamers who were indefinitely banned.

“We’re looking forward to welcoming back these creators and are optimistic they’ll contribute positively to the YouTube community,” the company said.

Creators who built their careers on YouTube may see this as a lifeline. But the uphill battle to rebuild their audience from zero will test whether a second chance can really lead to a comeback.